EnglandEngland
League OneLeague One
Round 33

Barnsley vs Peterborough Prediction & Betting Tips

17 Feb 2026
2-1
Full Time
Oakwell, Barnsley
Correct
Our #1 Pick
Total Goals
Over 2.5
2 : 1
FT

Betting Tips

51%
22%
27%
BarnsleyDrawPeterborough
Match Result
Barnsley
51%
Total Goals
Over 2.5
62%
Both Teams Score
Yes
62%
Double Chance
Home/Away
38%
Asian Handicap
AH Home -0.75
@ 2.01
50%
Odds updated hourly from bookmakers
Predictions recalculated every 2 hours
Locked 2 hours before kickoff

Expert Analysis

David Coleman
David Coleman Senior Football Analyst
75% 20+ yrs
6 min read

As Barnsley prepares to host Peterborough at Oakwell this Tuesday evening, all eyes are on D. Keillor-Dunn. The midfielder has been a beacon of inspiration for the Tykes, netting 13 goals this season — nearly a third of the team’s total. His ability to turn matches with moments of brilliance could b...

Read Full Analysis

Match Facts

Barnsley
Barnsley have gone 4 league matches without a win
Barnsley have received 4 red cards in 43 matches this season
D. Keillor-Dunn has been involved in 14 goals (13G + 1A)
Peterborough
Peterborough have scored all 4 penalties this season
Both teams scored in 12 of Peterborough's last 15 matches (80%)
H. Leonard has been involved in 13 goals (8G + 5A)
Peterborough conceded in the first half in 10 of their last 15 matches (67%)

Key Statistics

Barnsley9
4Draws
7Peterborough
2.45Avg Goals
50%BTTS
45%Over 2.5
17 Feb 2026Barnsley2-1Peterborough
6 Dec 2025Peterborough0-1Barnsley
19 Aug 2025Peterborough0-1Barnsley
21 Apr 2025Barnsley1-1Peterborough
29 Dec 2024Peterborough1-3Barnsley
View all H2H matches

Full Match Analysis

David Coleman
David Coleman
Senior Football Analyst
75% Accuracy
20+ Years Experience
5.5k Predictions

Keillor-Dunn’s Firepower Could Spark Barnsley’s Surprise Against Peterborough

As Barnsley prepares to host Peterborough at Oakwell this Tuesday evening, all eyes are on D. Keillor-Dunn. The midfielder has been a beacon of inspiration for the Tykes, netting 13 goals this season — nearly a third of the team’s total. His ability to turn matches with moments of brilliance could be pivotal in shaping the outcome of this midweek clash. The question is whether Keillor-Dunn’s influence can tip the scales against a resilient Peterborough side that has shown glimpses of strong form and defensive solidity.

Setting the Scene: League Position and Stakes

This fixture, while part of the regular League One rhythm, carries weight for both teams’ aspirations. Barnsley sits 15th with 37 points, eager to climb away from the lower half as they hunt for consistency. Peterborough, in 8th with 44 points, are eyeing a playoff push, making this a crucial game in their bid to tighten the gap on the top six. With each team eager for victory, the stakes are high, especially as the season edges towards its decisive final third.

Current Trajectory: Momentum and Recent Performances

When examining their latest form, Peterborough holds a slight edge. They’ve secured five wins in their last ten matches, with notable attacking prowess—averaging 2 goals per game and boasting a 60% BTTS rate. Their defense, however, remains vulnerable, conceding 1.4 goals per game but managing 8 clean sheets, indicating a team capable of tighten-up moments.

Barnsley, meanwhile, enters this fixture with a more unpredictable streak—just 2 wins in their last 10. Their goals per game stand at 1.5, but defensively, they leak more goals (2.3 on average), and the absence of clean sheets underlines defensive frailty. Yet, Barnsley's ability to score and create chances keeps them dangerous, especially with attacking talents like R. Cleary, whose 8 assists are a club high.

Strategic Blueprints: Tactics and Likely Lineups

Both teams line up in a 4-2-3-1 formation, emphasizing midfield control and quick transitions. Barnsley's approach probably revolves around Keillor-Dunn orchestrating attacks, supported by McGoldrick and Cleary, aiming to exploit pockets behind Peterborough’s defensive line. Their recent goalscoring record suggests an open, sometimes chaotic style, which could leave them susceptible at the back.

Peterborough’s tactical plan might hinge on their midfield duo’s discipline—K. Lisbie and J. Morgan—trying to stifle Barnsley’s creativity while pushing forward through H. Leonard, their top scorer with 8 goals. The Posh are likely to adopt a balanced approach, looking for opportunities to break quickly, especially on the counter, leveraging their decent clean sheet record (8 in total). Defensive solidity will be key for them to absorb Barnsley's pressure and exploit any gaps.

Players to Watch: Impact Makers on Both Sides

  • Barnsley:
    • D. Keillor-Dunn: The talismanic midfielder, whose ability to both score and create chances makes him the key threat.
    • D. McGoldrick: The versatile scorer, capable of unlocking defenses with his runs and finishing.
    • R. Cleary: The creative force, whose 8 assists underpin Barnsley's attacking moves.
  • Peterborough:
    • H. Leonard: The team's leading scorer, whose movement and finishing could be decisive.
    • K. Lisbie: A creative winger with 4 assists, capable of providing crucial delivery from wide areas.
    • J. Morgan: The midfield anchor, tasked with breaking up play and initiating attacks.

Head-to-Head Dynamics: Trends and Patterns

This fixture has seen a fairly balanced recent history, with 9 Barnsley wins, 7 Peterborough victories, and 4 draws over their last 20 meetings. The average goals tally hovers around 2.65, and the fixture has historically been competitive, with a 50% BTTS rate. Notably, Barnsley has won their last two meetings—both 1-0 victories—highlighting their ability to grind out results against Peterborough, though previous encounters have also produced high-scoring draws.

Betting Landscape: Odds, Probabilities, and Value

Bookmakers favor Barnsley slightly at 1.61, with a 45.7% implied probability for a home win. Peterborough’s odds stand at 2.15, with an implied 34.2% chance, indicating a relatively tight contest. The draw is priced at 3.65, approximately a 20.1% implied chance.

The over/under market sees a favorable 61% confidence in over 2.5 goals, supported by the teams' attacking records and recent scoring patterns. Both teams to score (BTTS) is also a solid option, with 64% confidence, given their offensive talents and defensive vulnerabilities.

Analyzing the Asian Handicap market, the -0.5 for Barnsley at 2.1 suggests slight value—if Barnsley can leverage home advantage and their recent head-to-head success, they could edge a tight game. Conversely, the +0.5 for Peterborough at 1.64 offers a cushion if they can keep the game close, which seems plausible based on their recent form and defensive resilience.

Forecasting the Final Score: What to Expect

Considering all indicators—the form, head-to-head trends, and goals data—the most probable result is a narrow victory for Barnsley, perhaps 2-1 or a 1-1 draw with both teams scoring. The 61% confidence in over 2.5 goals supports an open, end-to-end encounter with chances for both sides.

Predicted Outcome with Confidence

Our current assessment assigns a 44% confidence level to a Barnsley win, driven primarily by their home advantage and their ability to produce moments of quality from Keillor-Dunn. The over 2.5 goals bet holds a 61% confidence, aligning with their scoring tendencies and the defensive lapses we've seen lately.

Meanwhile, the BTTS market at 64% confidence fits neatly into the narrative of a game where both teams will find the net, especially given Barnsley's defensive struggles and Peterborough’s attacking talent.

Best Bets to Consider

  • Match Result: Barnsley to win at 1.61 — value considering their recent home performances and head-to-head success.
  • Goals Total: Over 2.5 goals at 1.87 — the attacking styles and recent scoring stats support this.
  • Both Teams to Score: Yes at 1.72 — consistent with their BTTS tendencies and offensive players.
  • Asian Handicap: Barnsley -0.5 at 2.10 — potential value if they capitalize on home advantage and attack-minded play.

In conclusion, this fixture promises an engaging contest with goals likely and both sides showing attacking intent. Barnsley's star Keillor-Dunn could be the difference-maker, but Peterborough’s resilience and goal-scoring options mean this game remains finely balanced. The best approach for bettors is to focus on the over goals and BTTS markets, where value and analytical backing are strongest.

---

Additional Information

BarnsleyBarnsley

Top Scorers

D. Keillor-Dunn
D. Keillor-DunnMidfielder
13Goals
D. McGoldrick
D. McGoldrickAttacker
6Goals
R. Cleary
R. ClearyAttacker
5Goals
A. Phillips
A. PhillipsMidfielder
4Goals
Patrick Kelly
Patrick KellyMidfielder
2Goals

Top Assists

R. Cleary
R. ClearyAttacker
8Assists
A. Phillips
A. PhillipsMidfielder
3Assists
Patrick Kelly
Patrick KellyMidfielder
3Assists
D. McGoldrick
D. McGoldrickAttacker
2Assists
L. Connell
L. ConnellMidfielder
2Assists

Cards

L. Connell
L. ConnellMidfielder
71
Jonathan Bland
Jonathan BlandMidfielder
70
Patrick Kelly
Patrick KellyMidfielder
40
J. Earl
J. EarlDefender
40
J. Shepherd
J. ShepherdDefender
40
PeterboroughPeterborough

Top Scorers

H. Leonard
H. LeonardAttacker
8Goals
K. Lisbie
K. LisbieAttacker
6Goals
J. Morgan
J. MorganAttacker
5Goals
M. Garbett
M. GarbettMidfielder
3Goals
G. Lindgren
G. LindgrenAttacker
3Goals

Top Assists

H. Leonard
H. LeonardAttacker
5Assists
A. Collins
A. CollinsMidfielder
5Assists
K. Lisbie
K. LisbieAttacker
4Assists
P. Kioso
P. KiosoDefender
2Assists
J. Morgan
J. MorganAttacker
1Assists

Cards

A. Collins
A. CollinsMidfielder
70
P. Kioso
P. KiosoDefender
70
H. Leonard
H. LeonardAttacker
60
K. Lisbie
K. LisbieAttacker
50
M. Garbett
M. GarbettMidfielder
50

Detailed Form & Recent Matches

Barnsley
WLLDD
10Played
2Wins
4Draws
4Losses
Points/Game1
Win %20%
Goals/Game2.1
Scored Avg0.9
Conceded Avg1.2
BTTS50%
Clean Sheets20%
Failed to Score40%

Recent Matches

28 AprWat Northampton1-0
25 AprLat Luton1-2
21 AprLat Stevenage0-1
18 AprDvs Bradford2-2
14 AprDat Port Vale0-0
Peterborough
DLDLL
10Played
1Wins
4Draws
5Losses
Points/Game0.7
Win %10%
Goals/Game2.9
Scored Avg1.3
Conceded Avg1.6
BTTS80%
Clean Sheets20%
Failed to Score10%

Recent Matches

28 AprDvs Mansfield Town0-0
25 AprLat Stockport County1-3
19 AprDvs Burton Albion1-1
16 AprLvs Port Vale1-3
11 AprLat Blackpool1-3

Head to Head History

Betting Statistics

MetricValue
Total Matches20
Average Goals2.45
BTTS50%
Over 2.5 Goals45%
Over 1.5 Goals75%

Goals by Team

TeamTotalAverage
Barnsley261.3 per game
Peterborough231.15 per game

Clean Sheets

TeamClean Sheets
Barnsley7 (35%)
Peterborough4 (20%)
17 Feb 2026League OneBarnsley2-1Peterborough
6 Dec 2025FA CupPeterborough0-1Barnsley
19 Aug 2025League OnePeterborough0-1Barnsley
21 Apr 2025League OneBarnsley1-1Peterborough
29 Dec 2024League OnePeterborough1-3Barnsley
29 Dec 2023League OnePeterborough2-2Barnsley
15 Aug 2023League OneBarnsley1-3Peterborough
7 May 2023League OneBarnsley0-2Peterborough
2 Dec 2022League OnePeterborough1-2Barnsley
18 Apr 2022ChampionshipBarnsley0-2Peterborough
27 Nov 2021ChampionshipPeterborough0-0Barnsley
26 Dec 2018League OneBarnsley2-0Peterborough
6 Oct 2018League OnePeterborough0-4Barnsley
19 Apr 2016League OneBarnsley1-0Peterborough
24 Nov 2015League OnePeterborough3-2Barnsley
18 Apr 2015League OneBarnsley1-1Peterborough
18 Oct 2014League OnePeterborough2-1Barnsley
1 Jan 2013ChampionshipPeterborough2-1Barnsley
2 Oct 2012ChampionshipBarnsley0-2Peterborough
24 Mar 2012ChampionshipBarnsley1-0Peterborough